Scientists who use generative artificial intelligence to help write federal grant applications tend to propose research topics that more closely resemble recently funded projects, according to a new study published in PNAS. At the National Institutes of Health, submissions with greater traces of AI writing were more likely to win funding, and awards with more AI traces were followed by modestly more publications in the first year or two, concentrated in routine studies rather than highly cited breakthroughs.
In the United States, much of academic science begins with a competitive grant proposal, a formal written application in which researchers pitch planned studies to federal agencies such as the National Science Foundation (NSF) and the National Institutes of Health (NIH) to compete for taxpayer funding. Over the past few years, scientists preparing academic texts have increasingly turned to large language models: artificial intelligence programs trained on massive collections of existing text, which generate and revise writing by predicting probable sequences of words. Because grant selection happens before experiments are funded, staffed, or published, shifts at the proposal stage can influence which scientific questions get pursued at all.
Earlier studies of academic publishing indicate that generative AI entered everyday scientific workflows rapidly after ChatGPT launched in late 2022. Tracking vocabulary shifts across preprints and journal articles through September 2024, a 2025 analysis of more than one million scientific papers estimated a steady climb in AI-modified writing, which reached an estimated 22 percent of the text in computer science papers. Similar tools also entered scientific gatekeeping, with a 2024 study of computer science conference peer reviews estimating that between 6.5 percent and 16.9 percent of submitted review text showed signs of substantial AI modification, particularly near submission deadlines.
Although language models can reduce the effort needed to polish complex prose, their reliance on patterns drawn from published papers and public grant archives has raised questions about whether they narrow the variety of scientific ideas. Because these systems tend to generate high-probability, field-typical phrasing, using them to prepare proposals could pull new projects closer to established norms. Consistent with that tension, a 2026 study of more than 41 million natural science papers found that scientists using AI tools published roughly three times as many papers and received nearly five times as many citations as peers who did not, yet the collective range of topics studied across science shrank by nearly 5 percent.
Source: PsyPost — Read the full article on the original site ↗
